Why Bulk Material Handling Problems Rarely Start in the Conveying Line
Problems start elsewhere.
When a pneumatic conveying system plugs, loses capacity or begins moving material inconsistently, the conveying line itself is often the first thing blamed. But the pipeline may only be revealing a problem that started somewhere else in the bulk material handling process.
Reliable pneumatic conveying depends on more than airflow through a pipe. Material characteristics, hopper discharge, feeding, air supply, dust collection, equipment condition and downstream receiving all affect how material moves through the system.
That is why troubleshooting a pneumatic conveying problem should begin by evaluating the complete material path, not simply the section of pipe where the symptom appears.
What Causes a Pneumatic Conveying Line to Plug?
Pneumatic conveying line plugging can result from insufficient conveying air, but adding more air is not always the solution. A blockage may originate with inconsistent material feeding, poor hopper discharge, air leakage, material buildup, filtration problems, excessive feed rates or conditions elsewhere in the process.
For example, if material enters the conveying line inconsistently, the system may periodically receive more material than the available airflow can reliably transport. The resulting blockage occurs in the pipeline, but the underlying problem may actually be at the hopper, feeder or material pickup point.
Likewise, moisture, cohesive material or changes in bulk density can alter how material enters and travels through the system.
The location of the blockage tells you where the system stopped working—not necessarily where the problem started.
Why Is My Pneumatic Conveying Rate Inconsistent?
Unstable conveying rates can occur when material is not introduced into the conveying air stream at a consistent rate.
A pneumatic conveying system must balance the amount of material entering the line with the airflow available to transport it. Changes in hopper discharge, feeder performance, material characteristics or air volume can disrupt that balance.
The result may appear as fluctuating throughput, surging, intermittent plugging or periods when the system cannot maintain the required production rate.
Before increasing blower capacity or replacing conveying equipment, the material feed conditions should therefore be evaluated along with the conveying system itself.
Can Hopper Design Affect Pneumatic Conveying Performance?
Yes. A pneumatic conveying system cannot consistently transport material that is not consistently available at its pickup point.
Poor hopper discharge can result from bridging, ratholing, compaction, inconsistent feeding or material characteristics that were not adequately considered when the storage and discharge equipment was designed.
These conditions can starve the conveying line at one moment and overload it the next.
Evaluating hopper geometry, discharge characteristics, feeding equipment and the physical properties of the material can reveal problems that might otherwise be mistaken for pneumatic conveying failures.
Can Dust Collection Affect a Pneumatic Conveying System?
Yes. Dust collection and pneumatic conveying should not always be treated as independent systems.
Filtration affects airflow, pressure and the ability of a system to separate conveyed material from the conveying air. Dirty or improperly selected filters can restrict airflow, while ineffective dust control can contribute to material accumulation, housekeeping problems and equipment wear.
Effective dust collection can also help control fugitive dust, protect equipment and maintain a cleaner production environment.
For these reasons, Air Dynamics evaluates dust collection as part of the overall material handling process when the two systems interact rather than treating each piece of equipment as an isolated component.
Why Does Pneumatic Conveying Equipment Wear Out Prematurely?
Excessive wear can be another indication that the overall conveying system is not properly matched to the material or process.
Abrasive powders and bulk solids can wear piping, bends, valves and other components. Conveying velocity, piping configuration and material characteristics all influence the rate of abrasion.
Increasing airflow to overcome another conveying problem can sometimes make wear worse because higher material velocity increases the forces acting on system components.
The better approach is to determine why the system requires the additional airflow and whether the material, velocity and equipment configuration are properly matched.
Why Is My Product Being Damaged During Pneumatic Conveying?
Product degradation can occur when fragile materials travel at excessive velocity or repeatedly impact piping, bends and receiving equipment.
Pellets, granules, food ingredients, pharmaceutical materials and other friable products may require a different conveying approach than durable powders or bulk solids.
System selection therefore should consider more than whether the material can physically travel through a pipe. Engineers should also evaluate particle characteristics, acceptable product degradation, conveying distance, required throughput and the number of bends or transitions in the material path.
Depending on the application, those requirements may influence whether vacuum conveying, pressure conveying, dilute phase conveying or dense phase conveying is appropriate.
Why Does Material Segregate During Conveying?
Bulk materials containing particles with different sizes, densities or shapes may separate as they are transported or discharged.
Material velocity, conveying mode, pipeline configuration and receiving conditions can all influence segregation. For processes that depend on maintaining a consistent blend, the consequences can extend beyond the conveying system and affect downstream product quality.
This is another reason pneumatic conveying design should begin with an understanding of the material and process rather than simply selecting equipment based on conveying distance and capacity.
Should I Add More Air When a Pneumatic Conveying Line Plugs?
Not automatically.
Increasing airflow may temporarily help move material through a problem area, but it can also increase energy consumption, equipment wear and product degradation without correcting the condition that caused the blockage.
The better question is: Why did the material stop moving at the required airflow in the first place?
The answer may involve the material feed rate, hopper discharge, piping configuration, air leakage, filtration, material buildup, receiver capacity or another component of the process.
Troubleshooting should identify that root cause before equipment or operating parameters are changed.
What Parts of a Bulk Material Handling System Should Be Evaluated?
A complete bulk material handling evaluation follows the material from the beginning of the process to its final destination.
Material may move through receiving, storage, hopper discharge, feeding, transfer, batching, pneumatic conveying, processing, separation and collection before reaching its final destination.
A problem at any one of those stages can affect the performance of the stages that follow.
For example, inconsistent discharge from storage can create conveying instability. Poor filtration can reduce available airflow. A receiver that cannot discharge material quickly enough can restrict the entire conveying process.
Looking at the complete material path helps engineers distinguish between the location of the symptom and the source of the problem.
When Should a Pneumatic Conveying System Be Evaluated?
A system evaluation should be considered when a facility experiences recurring line plugging, inconsistent throughput, excessive equipment wear, product degradation, material segregation, fugitive dust or unexplained maintenance events.
It is particularly important when individual components have already been repaired, replaced or adjusted but the same operating problem continues.
Repeated equipment changes without identifying the underlying cause can increase cost while simply moving the problem somewhere else in the process.
How Does Air Dynamics Approach Pneumatic Conveying Problems?
Air Dynamics Industrial Systems Corporation designs pneumatic conveying and bulk material handling systems around the material, process and operating requirements of the facility.
Rather than beginning with a predetermined piece of equipment, our engineers evaluate factors such as material characteristics, required throughput, pickup and discharge conditions, conveying distance, piping configuration, airflow requirements, filtration, dust control, controls and upstream and downstream equipment.
Air Dynamics provides custom vacuum and pressure pneumatic conveying systems for powders, granules and other dry bulk materials across applications including food and beverage manufacturing, pharmaceutical processing, chemicals, energy, metals, plastics and general manufacturing.
The objective is not simply to make material move through a pipeline. It is to engineer a reliable bulk material handling process from pickup through final collection or discharge.
Experiencing Pneumatic Conveying Problems?
If your conveying system is plugging, losing capacity, damaging product or requiring repeated maintenance, replacing the equipment at the point of failure may not solve the problem.
Air Dynamics can evaluate the complete material path to identify where the problem actually begins and engineer a solution around your process.
Explore Additional Resources
